Trucking News

Appeals Court Sides With New York Over Non-Domiciled CDLs

· By Maas Logistics Editorial Team · 8 min read

Updated

Saturday roundup from Melissa, Texas, heavy on policy and capacity: a federal appeals court ruled DOT was wrong to hold back New York's highway money over non-domiciled CDLs, about 100,000 tractors have left the for-hire market in a year, carriers are hearing two different dates for swapping out revoked ELDs, a trucker restroom-access bill gets a Senate committee look Wednesday, and a Friday evening wreck tied up I-35 in Laredo. Moving dry van or reefer out of DFW before Thanksgiving? Send your lanes to an asset carrier for a quote: https://maaslogistic.com/quote.

Appeals court sides with New York over non-domiciled CDL funding

FreightWaves' John Kingston and the Associated Press both reported Nov. 13 that a three-judge panel of the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled unanimously for New York in State of New York v. U.S. Department of Transportation (No. 26-1097). The panel found FMCSA acted in an "arbitrary and capricious" way when DOT held back $73,502,543 in April — about 4% of New York's normal funding, which AP rounds to nearly $74 million — after the state declined to cancel its non-domiciled CDLs.

FMCSA's complaint was that New York had issued non-domiciled CDLs that stayed valid past the holder's authorized stay in the country. The court's answer: the federal rules on the books at the time had no requirement that a license expiration match that authorized stay, and FMCSA itself conceded the plain text didn't say so. FreightWaves puts the number of affected non-domiciled CDL and learner's permit holders at about 32,600, roughly 7% of New York's licenses; AP says nearly 33,000.

FreightWaves also notes a similar dispute between the federal government and California is still pending at the D.C. Circuit. Read plainly, Friday's ruling is about funding and fair notice under the rules that existed then. It isn't the last word on federal CDL policy, and more court decisions and rulemaking are likely, so the rules on who can hold a CDL may keep moving.

What it means: What it means for CDL drivers: Whatever happens in court, keep your license, medical card and any required documents current, and know your own state's renewal rules before they catch you on the road. Maas hires company drivers 23 and older with 3 years of experience — https://maaslogistic.com/drive-with-us/company-drivers. What it means for Texas shippers: Shifting driver-qualification rules are one more reason to know exactly who is hauling your load. Our https://maaslogistic.com/blog/carrier-vetting-checklist lists what to ask, and https://maaslogistic.com/blog/2026-10-14-asset-based-carrier-vs-freight-broker-dfw-shippers explains asset carriers versus brokers. Maas runs its own trucks with its own drivers and never re-brokers.

About 100,000 trucks have left the for-hire market in a year

FreightWaves' Nov. 13 market update, with Julie Van de Kamp, says the U.S. for-hire market has lost roughly 100,000 tractors over the past year, including about 51,000 in one summer month. That puts the active tractor count at its lowest since early 2022. The losses are at the two ends: carriers running 1 to 6 trucks have given back their entire pandemic-era growth, and fleets over 1,000 trucks are down about 9%. Fleets of 20 to 1,000 trucks, meanwhile, are up 12% over five years.

The rate picture from the same update: overall tender rejections (SONAR STRI) were 12.87%, reefer rejections have sat around 20–21% since late September, and dry van was 10.4%. Contract linehaul (VCRPM1) reached $2.88 a mile, 25% above a year ago. The STVI volume index is up about 4% since Oct. 1, from 11,068 to 11,405, even with a 3–4% dip on the week. Van de Kamp pointed to early pre-peak tightening out of California and rising volume in parts of Texas and the western Midwest, and told shippers to budget for higher contract rates heading into 2027.

Commercial Carrier Journal's Pamella De Leon (Nov. 13) adds FTR's outlook: diesel averaged above $5.50 a gallon in the third quarter, against FTR's January forecast near $3.65, and FTR expects diesel to still be about 40% above that January forecast at the end of 2027. EPA's 2027 NOx rule still isn't final, even with a Jan. 1 effective date.

What it means: What it means for Texas shippers: Capacity is settling into mid-size asset fleets, and reefer is the tightest of all. Lock in Thanksgiving and December reefer and dry van loads now, and build 2027 bids expecting higher contract rates and higher fuel. See https://maaslogistic.com/services/refrigerated-trucking and https://maaslogistic.com/services/dry-van-trucking, plan with our https://maaslogistic.com/blog/2026-11-01-peak-season-freight-shipping-truckload-shipper-guide, https://maaslogistic.com/blog/2026-11-04-truckload-rfp-guide-2027-freight-bid-shippers and https://maaslogistic.com/blog/2026-11-13-trucking-fuel-surcharge-explained-shipper-guide, and request a quote at https://maaslogistic.com/quote. What it means for owner-operators: One-truck operations are getting squeezed hardest by fuel and a slow rate recovery. Leasing on with an asset carrier is one option — Maas pays 87–90% of gross with non-forced dispatch: https://maaslogistic.com/drive-with-us/owner-operators.

Revoked ELDs: two dates are going around, and an Arkansas sweep puts 393 out of service

Friday's roundup covered the revocation itself: https://maaslogistic.com/news/2026-11-13-fmcsa-revokes-133-elds-reefer-demand-jumps-supply-driven-recovery.

The new wrinkle is timing. DOT's Nov. 12 release gives carriers "up to 60 days" to replace a revoked device, but it also tells officers to cite drivers and put them out of service for running one on or after Nov. 24, 2026. The Commercial Vehicle Safety Alliance's Nov. 13 regulatory update says the devices have to be replaced before Jan. 12, 2027, with out-of-service enforcement for use on or after Jan. 12. CDLWire flagged the same mismatch. Until FMCSA clears it up, the safe plan is to treat Nov. 24 as the deadline.

Bulk Transporter (Nov. 13) reports the third wave of FMCSA's Operation Highway Shield, a 48-hour multiagency sweep in Arkansas, put 393 drivers and vehicles out of service. Officers found 183 English-language-proficiency violations and 74 immigration violations, made 44 criminal arrests and recovered a stolen trailer. FMCSA is also offering up to $7 million in research funding on fatal Class 7 and 8 truck crashes, with applications due Dec. 28.

What it means: What it means for CDL drivers and owner-operators: This weekend, check your ELD's name, model and identifier against FMCSA's revoked list yourself, keep paper logs in the truck, and expect more roadside inspections through the holidays. Brush up with our https://maaslogistic.com/blog/2026-10-30-hours-of-service-rules-for-truck-drivers-guide and https://maaslogistic.com/blog/2026-11-09-cdl-pre-trip-inspection-checklist-truck-drivers. What it means for Texas shippers: An out-of-service order in the middle of a load is a missed appointment. Ask carriers how they handle hours compliance — the questions are in our https://maaslogistic.com/blog/carrier-vetting-checklist.

Trucker Bathroom Access Act goes to a Senate committee Nov. 18

Truck News' Eugene Mulero (Nov. 13) reports the bipartisan Trucker Bathroom Access Act, from Sens. Lisa Blunt Rochester (D-Del.) and Deb Fischer (R-Neb.), is set for consideration by the Senate Commerce, Science and Transportation Committee on Nov. 18. It would require businesses that receive freight deliveries or pickups to let drivers use restrooms already open to their employees, customers or visitors, subject to reasonable safety and security requirements. It would not require anyone to build new restrooms.

A House version from Reps. Troy Nehls (R-Texas) and Chrissy Houlahan (D-Pa.) cleared the House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee in May as part of the Build America 250 Act. ATA, OOIDA and Women In Trucking support it. Floor time in the lame-duck session is short, so whether it passes this year is an open question.

What it means: What it means for Texas shippers and receivers: You don't have to wait on Congress. Letting drivers use the restroom at your dock costs nothing, and drivers remember which docks treat them right — especially during long peak-season waits. Plan your holiday freight with our https://maaslogistic.com/blog/2026-11-01-peak-season-freight-shipping-truckload-shipper-guide and request a quote at https://maaslogistic.com/quote. What it means for CDL drivers: Maas company drivers run 50+ CPM dry van and 60+ CPM reefer — https://maaslogistic.com/drive-with-us/company-drivers.

Short: tractor-trailer and car crash on I-35 in Laredo

KGNS' Angie Bravo reports a tractor-trailer and a small car collided Friday evening near the 4100 block of southbound Interstate 35 in Laredo, blocking the inner lane and the left outer shoulder. Police had not said whether anyone was hurt.

What it means: What it means for CDL drivers: Build some slack into border-lane runs and check traffic before the last miles into Laredo. Lane notes are at https://maaslogistic.com/lanes/melissa-to-laredo and https://maaslogistic.com/lanes/dallas-fort-worth-freight-shipping.

Saturday note: shipping or driving out of DFW

Shipping dry van or reefer out of DFW before Thanksgiving? Get a quote from an asset-based carrier that never re-brokers: https://maaslogistic.com/quote. CDL-A drivers: 50+ CPM dry van / 60+ CPM reefer — apply as a company driver: https://maaslogistic.com/drive-with-us/company-drivers. Owner-operators: 87–90% of gross, non-forced dispatch: https://maaslogistic.com/drive-with-us/owner-operators.

What it means: Maas Logistics LLC | 1817 Miller Rd #5, Melissa, TX 75454 | (916) 770-7323 | dispatch@maaslogistic.com | Melissa, TX / DFW | USDOT 3179194. The Logistics Partner that Delivers. Read more at https://maaslogistic.com/news.

Running with Maas

Hiring CDL-A company drivers: company driver openings. Owner-operators: lease on with Maas. Need a truck: get a freight quote.

Maas Logistics LLC | 1817 Miller Rd #5, Melissa, TX 75454 | (916) 770-7323 | dispatch@maaslogistic.com

Dallas–Fort Worth | USDOT 3179194

The Logistics Partner that Delivers.

Need a truck this week?

Send us the lane and we'll come back with a rate the same business day. Dispatch answers 24/7 at (916) 770-7323.